As an American, I cannot go to any other country and stay an unlimited amount of time, get a drivers license, vote in statewide elections, or even get a job. So what is this nonsense put forward by the left that only criminal illegals are to be deported but not the noncriminal illegals. If you're here illegally, you have broken the rules and have accepted the risk that you can be deported at any time, period.
Surely, noncriminal illegals play an important role in the workings of the American economy. For example, field workers, landscape workers, caretakers for the elderly and handicapped, and construction workers. We need these people who perform jobs that Americans will not (why should Americans work if they can be supported by government handouts), but there needs to be a system of documentation and accountability. The system is completely broken and a free for all with massive abuse of the American taxpayer.
The US desperately need a guest worker program that is transparent and verifiable. One in which we get the benefit of foreign workers and they get the benefit of a good wage. One that minimizes fraud and abuse.
Some suggestions of how it may look:
All existing illegal immigrants must come forward to be documented or risk deportation with no ability to achieve guest worker status in the future.
US employers to make official requests for guest workers (?application fee, to be paid by employer). Guest worker status granted for an initial trial period, then extended if appropriate. A minimum wage is established for the guest worker.
An initial guest worker visa can only be issued to someone outside the country.
Comprehensive vetting of the guest worker applicant and reliable, unalterable forms of identification.
No birthright citizenship for guest workers. No chain migration. Guest worker's family does not get the right to join the guest worker. (It is the guest worker's decision to separate the family).
Guest worker does not pay federal taxes or Social Security tax but he/employer does pay State tax if applicable. Guest workers/employer are required to pay into a distinct medicaid fund and for a limited disability benefit which are only in effect if he/she is working and only provides benefits until the expiration of his current guest worker visa. (the guest worker assumes the risk).
If guest worker is unemployed, he/she can stay in the country while the guest worker visa is valid at their expense and risk, or return to his/her native country. He/she can look for a guest worker job while the visa is valid.
Guest worker must pay for his/her return ticket to their native country prior to arrival in the US as part of the application process.
Possible pathway to citizenship after residing for a minimum of ?12 years and achieving certain definable goals such as language, civics, employment record, employer sponsorship.
The guest worker is not entitled to government benefits such as food stamps and section 8 housing. He/she is not eligible for social security or medicare.
He/she cannot vote in federal elections and is not counted in the census for the benefit of congressional districting or electoral votes.
Guest worker is prohibited from access to firearms.
Any criminal activity results in revocation of guest worker visa and immediate deportation.
Currently a foreign national can come into the US illegally or overstay their visa, and take advantage of our system. This is not a system that is safe and beneficial to the US. A sensible guest worker program is needed by the United States as foreign nationals play an integral role in the US economy. A program where both the guest worker and the US benefit from the opportunity yet one that protects the interests of both parties from fraud and abuse.